Cookie preferences

HundrED uses cookies to enhance user experiences, to personalise content, and analyse our web traffic. By clicking "Accept all" you agree to the use of all cookies, including marketing cookies that may help us deliver personalised marketing content to users. By selecting "Accept necessary" only essential cookies, such as those needed for basic functionality and internal analytics, will be enabled.
For more details, please review our Cookie Policy.
Accept all
Accept necessary
search
clear

EdTech Tulna

place India

Establish quality standards, evaluate EdTech products, empower decision-makers

Historically, there have existed no quality standards for EdTech solutions, making it hard for users to make informed decisions and for suppliers to build quality products. EdTech Tulna, a product evaluation tool aims to bridge this gap. Tulna, meaning, ‘to compare’ in Sanskrit, builds quality standards for EdTech product design and conducts evaluations to allow for comparison between products.

Shortlisted

Overview

HundrED shortlisted this innovation

HundrED has shortlisted this innovation to one of its innovation collections. The information on this page has been checked by HundrED.

Web presence

2020

Established

5M

Children

1

Countries
Target group
Students basic
Updated
April 2023
Given existing evidence that well-designed products have a positive impact on learning outcomes, we create of quality standards for EdTech. These standards can lead to informed adoption of EdTech and can influence the build of standard-aligned products, leading to the creation and adoption of quality products that will positively impact learning outcomes.

About the innovation

Why did you create this innovation?

With an abundance of EdTech solutions in the market, governments are unable to select suitable solutions and children struggle to learn. On the market side, product companies struggle to signal quality of their product. Tulna bridges this gap through a shared understanding of what good EdTech looks like and provides easy comparison between products to help users make informed decisions.

What does your innovation look like in practice?

Tulna provides users with information to help them make decisions around EdTech.

1) It creates standards and toolkits to build a common understanding of what quality product design looks like
2) Builds government capacity to make informed decisions around EdTech adoption by leveraging the standards and toolkits
3) Publishes product evaluations that help product companies signal their quality

Tulna is built on existing global research and literature on teaching-learning principles, effective pedagogical strategies, and quality product design for different use-cases of EdTech; to build a common understanding of ‘what good looks like’. It is put into practice by a team of trained technical experts who understand how to implement and impart training on the rubrics, toolkits and evaluation materials. Tulna’s standards, toolkits and rubrics are currently proprietary, but can be leveraged free of cost, and are used by multiple stakeholders, such as governments and think tanks, today.

How has it been spreading?

Tulna has seen tremendous success in the short time since its launch. Through continued efforts of the team, it has been adopted by 3 state governments in their EdTech software procurement processes. Used as a technical evaluation framework, Tulna has supported the adoption and uptake of quality personalised adaptive learning solutions and digital classrooms in Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh and Haryana. This procurement has impacted the learning of over 5 million children, influencing government spending of 173 million USD. Tulna has also conducted independent evaluations of 14 product companies that are publicly available and help these organisations to signal quality. Over the next few years, Tulna’s goal is to be adopted by 8 state governments and to continue independent evaluations.

If I want to try it, what should I do?

Tulna has been built on global evidence around product design, making it easy to contextualise for other geographies. Within India, it can be adopted and implemented with ease by reaching out to the core team. Globally, it will require the presence of a local research team that will be supported by the core team in their journey of contextualisation.

Implementation steps

Instance 1 Product company Step 1
Why should they use it: To signal quality of their product and build standard-aligned solutions for learners/implementers
Instance 1 Product company Step 2
How should they seek it out: Should reach out to the Tulna team via the website. This is followed by a product demo with the technical team to map the product to an existing framework.
Instance 1 Product company Step 3
Tulna evaluation: Once aligned, the product company signs a consent form, allowing expert evaluators front-end access to their product; the evaluation commences with the evaluators reviewing 20-30% of the product content, and mapping it to Tulna frameworks and rubrics. The Tulna team will create a detailed report on how the product has fared across different criteria, including screenshots of the platform, rationale for scoring etc.
Instance 1 Product company Step 4
What happens after: Once the evaluation is complete, the evaluation report is published in the public domain, along with a company response to give the readers a 360 view of the product. Companies can use the company response to clarify design decisions, speak out about future build etc.
Instance 2 Government adoption Step 1
Why should they use Tulna: Governments wishing to procure quality software and make an informed decision based on a comparable analysis of products in the market, can use EdTech Tulna as their technical evaluation framework in their procurement process.
Instance 2 Government adoption Step 2
How should they seek it out: National, state or district governments can reach out to Tulna via the website, or via its parent company Central Square Foundation to indicate interest in leveraging Tulna for their procurement. Tulna also proactively reaches out to state governments to check for interest.
Instance 2 Government adoption Step 3
Tulna evaluation: Once Tulna has been mentioned in the procurement document and the procurement bid has been closed, the Tulna team visits the state government to train evaluators on how to use the Tulna frameworks and rubrics for evaluation. Post the training, the evaluators commence the evaluations and score products accordingly.
Instance 2 Government adoption Step 4
What happens after: Basis the technical evaluation, a quality-aligned, contextually relevant solution is adopted by the state, and is deployed in the selected geographies.
Instance 3 Institutional investors Step 1
Why should they use Tulna: Investors can use Tulna either to strengthen the quality of their existing portfolio of EdTech products or to make fresh, quality-aligned investments.
Instance 3 Institutional investors Step 2
How should they seek it out: Investors can reach out to the Tulna team via the Tulna website and indicate interest in using it as part of their model.
Instance 3 Institutional investors Step 3
Tulna evaluation: Once onboard, the Tulna technical team will conduct evaluations of products in the portfolio or those who have applied to be part of the portfolio. These evaluations will be based on existing frameworks and rubrics. Different from an independent product evaluation, this evaluation will be done in a smaller frame of time and will consist of pure scoring, rather than the production of an evaluation report that includes screenshots of the product, examples etc.
Instance 3 Institutional investors Step 4
What happens after: Once the evaluations are complete, the Tulna team will share the scores with the investment committee, and answer any questions on scoring, performance etc. Following this, the investment committee can make an informed decision according to performance on different criteria, on who to select for their portfolio or on how to strengthen the quality of their existing portfolio.
Instance 4 International adoption Step 1
Why should they use Tulna: To help users in their geographies make informed decisions around EdTech products and support companies in building standard-aligned solutions.
Instance 4 International adoption Step 2
How should they seek it out: They should contact the Tulna team via the website or through the parent company to indicate interest in creating an international instance of Tulna.
Instance 4 International adoption Step 3
Tulna implemented: This model would require a local team to lead the contextualisation efforts (ex. aligning Tulna to local curriculums, prioritise which use-cases are relevent for users etc) and will be supported by the core team in their journey. Both parties working together will build out a global instance for Tulna which can then be carried forward by the local team.

Spread of the innovation

loading map...